A Lesbian's Perspective Of Fried Green Tomatoes

2742 words - 11 pages

A Lesbian's Perspective of Fried Green Tomatoes

Last week my mother and I decided to rent a "woman's film," Fried Green Tomatoes. We sat mesmerized for 1 hour and 45 minutes by the narrative played out upon our small screen. However, as I realized by our discussion after the film, we had two very different experiences. While she enjoyed the film as a story about two "best friends," I read this friendship as an obvious lesbian relationship hidden within the repressed text of a popular, commercial film. A few months later, at a screening of Silence of the Lambs, the same scenario was replayed. A lesbian friend and I interpreted the absence of confirmed heterosexuality in Jodie Foster's androgynous character as an indication of a lesbian depiction. Angered by our interpretation, a skeptical
heterosexual friend accused us of seeing "gayness" everywhere, that we were inventing a space for ourselves that doesn't exist in mainstream America.

The study of gay and lesbian receptions and interpretations of mainstream media texts is based on assertions such as John Fiske's that "meanings are determined socially: they are constructed out of the conjuncture of the text with the socially situated reader" (80). However, often gay film reviewers criticize these films for their refusals to grant characters a clear lesbian identity. The largest national gay magazine, The Advocate, charges Fried Green Tomatoes with the crime of delesbianization, and argues that "Hollywood has always been partial to deepsixing gay and lesbian material... Its not that the town dislikes lesbians altogether. In fact, if they're mini skirted, ice- pick-wielding psychopaths, the studios will spare no expense in bringing their stories to the screen, as shown most spectacularly in Basic Instinct" (Ehrenstein, 67). In an age where the AIDS virus has increased homophobia and sexual repression, a positive and "out" gay/lesbian portrayal is becoming less and less of an option within the capitalist institution of the commercial cinema.

Criticism, such as The Advocate's, is one way to read the Hollywood "delesbianized" text, but it is a bleak and depressing outlook. It suggests that gays and lesbians are so disempowered that enjoyment cannot be taken in the form of popular pleasure, that there is no place for gays and lesbians within popular culture. It is important to regard Hollywood as a producer of discourse. Although mainstream film tends to reinforce dominant ideology as a form of social control and as an appeal to the majority of consumers, as discourse it transmits and produces power - but it also undermines it. Commercial film "can be both an instrument and an effect of power, but also a hindrance, a stumbling block, a point of resistance, and a starting point for an opposing strategy (Foucault, 101).

The opposing strategy that gay and lesbian film studies offers is an active subtextual reading of popular texts against the dominant discourse. Stick a reading, to a...

Find Another Essay On A Lesbian's Perspective of Fried Green Tomatoes

Cultural Mythologies and Binary Oppositions in the Novel and Film, Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe

1631 words - 7 pages and directors presentations of binary oppositions. Both in novel and film the exercise of binary oppositions are used to stress a significant thematic concern. In the novel Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Café, the binary oppositions of heterosexual and homosexual relationships are used to emphasize the author's resistance to the cultural mythology to facilitate the heterosexual relationship in comparison to the functions of a

A Feminist Perspective of Othello Essay

2534 words - 10 pages A Feminist Perspective of  Othello      Throughout the length of Shakespeare’s tragedy Othello there is a steady undercurrent of sexism. It is originating from not one, but rather various male characters in the play, who manifest prejudicial, discriminatory attitudes toward women.   In the opening scene, while Iago is expressing his hatred for the general Othello for his having chosen Michael Cassio for the lieutenancy, he

Welty's Characterization in A Curtain of Green

2612 words - 10 pages Welty's Characterization in A Curtain of Green          Myth, symbol, and allusion are not an uncommon characteristic in Eudora Welty's works. By using characters such as Odysseus and leaving hints of symbolism in works such as The Optimist's Daughter Welty places many questions in the minds of her readers. After a reader has pondered these questions a categorization of the story takes place in the readers mind. Although different readers

A cultural feminist perspective of HBO's Trueblood

1083 words - 5 pages of female gender roles in the minds of viewers. Peforming a textual analysis on various episodes from season one of Trueblood, I will be applying the cultural feminist perspective to examine how female characters are objectified to attract a male audience, viewers are given a false representation of female empowerment to draw in the “educated” female audience, and how female sexuality is defined by masculine hegemony perpetuated by both men and

A Feminist Perspective of William Shakespeare

1532 words - 6 pages A Feminist Perspective of Shakespeare      Although William Shakespeare reflects and at times supports the English Renaissance stereotypes of women and men and their various roles and responsibilities in society, he is also a writer who questions, challenges, and modifies those representations. His stories afford opportunities not only to understand Renaissance culture better but also to confront our own contemporary generalizations about

Truth is a matter of Perspective

925 words - 4 pages basic. This is realism since he is describing that actually happened during the days of the civil wars basic training. Now this does show his experience but after the Young Recruit Chapter he moves to a new perspective but not everyone agrees what he hears from a friend. Not everyone prefer Mr. Goss using part of a story that is heard from a friend. Mr. Conn Norwich is one of those people by this statement from Preface “The title of these

A Psychoanalytical Perspective of Susan Glaspell’s Trifle

1086 words - 4 pages The psychoanalytical perspective is a method of shifting from a hidden to an obvious subject matter which encompasses a process of awareness as well as translation (The Free Dictionary by Farlex, 2010). From a psychoanalyst perspective I will examine the linguistic symbolism of the text in the short play, “Trifle” to arrive at the underlying suppressed concepts of the author. Susan Glaspell- an Iowa native- filled her play with a hint of

origin of religion from a psychological perspective

788 words - 4 pages To answer the question of why religion exists is a very daunting task, and without a doubt any theory will be controversial. I chose to examine this question from a purely psychological and scientific perspective. It is argued that humans may be genetically predisposed to be religious behavior, or that we are simply reacting to our environment. Religion may even exist because of the human desire to pursue happiness. All three of these

A broadening perspective of the hero's journey

807 words - 4 pages use of the hero's journey in their writing but from a different perspective. Christopher Marlowe's 16th century work, Doctor Faustus, follows another form of the hero's journey, the flip side of Beowulf, as one sells his soul to the devil and pursues more evil desires. While both protagonists are entirely different they both remarkably follow the same journey of showing a great division over time in what one might consider to be a hero. The

Perspective of Aging: A Phenomenological Approach

1394 words - 6 pages Perspective of aging: A phenomenological approach Introduction Aging is the process by which the human body undergoes changes and maturation over time, mainly because dead cells are not replaced in sufficient amounts to maintain optimum performance. In addition, changes in behavior are expected, (Gall, Beins, and Feldman, 2001). Due to the distinctive physical and psychological changes, this period of life can be one of much confusion for the

A Freudian Perspective of Shakespeare's Macbeth

2638 words - 11 pages Macbeth:  A Freudian Perspective       Macbeth and Lady Macbeth  We may take as an example of a person who collapses on reaching success, after striving for it with single-minded energy, the figure of Shakespeare's Lady Macbeth. Beforehand there is no hesitation, no sign of any internal conflict in her, no endeavour but that of overcoming the scruples of her ambitious and yet tender-minded husband. She is ready to sacrifice even her

Similar Essays

"Fried Green Tomatoes" By Fannie Flag

1118 words - 4 pages The topic of race has always been a heated issue among the 'worlds' conversation.' The South exemplifies this 'world,' the Changing South. In the South, race played a role that was not encountered anywhere else in the United States, maybe even the world. Fannie Flag's book, Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe displays the lasting effect of race relations in a richly comic, poignant narrative. Throughout the story, race is brought up

Older Adult: The Notebook And Fried Green Tomatoes Film Analysis

2917 words - 12 pages impairment, but it affects the family unit as a whole. Family members must deal with the fact that they are loosing the person that they once knew. The act of reminiscing is seen from a different perspective in the movie Fried Green Tomatoes. Two women become unexpected friends and help each other with feeling valued, thus increasing each other’s self-esteem. Ninny Threadgood lives in a nursing home and is need of more socialization. When she meets

Character Sketch On Idgie Threadgoode From "Fried Green Tomatoes"

1314 words - 5 pages about and scrape her knees, get black eyes, and get dirty, and that's just what she did. Not even her own Momma could control her. Idgie was definitely the wild child in the book "Fried Green Tomatoes". When Buddy died, Idgie ran off and didn't let anyone in her family come near her. She would come home only time after time to see how her family was doing, but she spent most of her life independently, away from civilization. Idgie didn't want to

Powerful Characters And Powerful Themes In Fried Green Tomatoes At The Whistle Stop Café

1570 words - 6 pages One Southern novel shines light on racism, feminism, and surprising lesbianism. Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Café by Fannie Flagg, published in 1987, is about the different events happening and people living in Whistle Stop and Birmingham, Alabama. Fannie Flagg uses many powerful characters to enforce several themes. Idgie, Ruth, Evelyn, Mrs. Threadgoode, Big George, Artis, and Jasper are a few of the main characters that help
Putlockers | Éclairage de nouveauté | Chris Hardwick, Leslie Bibb, Nore Davis