Joseph Bedier's The Romance Of Tristan And Iseult And Jean Cocteau’s Eternal Return

959 words - 4 pages

The Romance of Tristan and Iseult, by Joseph Bédier, and Jean Cocteau’s 1943 cinematic adaptation of the epic love story Eternal Return, both portray the love between Tristan and Iseult, and Patrice and Natalie as an agonizing cancer that overpowers the lovers after they consume the love potion. But the differences of how and when the love potion is administered, and the lovers’ feelings for each other before the potion is drunk, reveal different depictions of the love potion between the novel and the film.

The first difference between the film and the novel is when the two lovers drink the love potion. In the book, they drink the love potion when they are still on the boat and have “dropped anchor by an island” (Bédier, 42). Here Iseult has not met King Mark. But in the film, Natalie and Patrice drink the love potion after Natalie has been introduced to Uncle Mark. In the first instance, they both have a chance to elope, and no one would be the wiser. They can easily live a life of comfort and full of love with each other, but Tristan chooses to hand over the woman he loves to his Uncle, and suffer for his love. In the film, Natalie and Patrice are not given this option, and therefore do not have a chance to escape their faith. Also in the book, an unknowing maid gives the love potion to the lovers. She believes that she is just giving them wine. This signifies the fact that no one intentionally wished for them to suffer, but faith led them to it. But in the film, Achille puts the love potion in their drinks on the pretext of murdering them with poison. In the film the fact that the love potion is labeled poison, foreshadows the pain and sorrow the two lovers will face, because poison leads to a slow and suffering death, just as the love between the characters is portrayed as a pestilence.

In the book, Iseult loves Tristan before the love potion. When Tristan is injured after battling the dragon and Iseult is healing him “Her glance linger[s] on the face of [Tristan]; she [sees] that he [is] beautiful” (Bédier, 32). Here she is already falling for him. She also gets upset when he says that she will marry King Mark, and “tremble[s] for shame and anguish…it [is] to another that he [is] delivering her” (Bédier, 37). In these two instances before the love potion is drunk, Iseult is already showing signs of affection for Tristan, albeit as much as the decorum of the day allows her. In the film, Natalie also shows her love for Patrice before they consume...

Find Another Essay On Joseph Bedier's The Romance of Tristan and Iseult and Jean Cocteau’s Eternal Return

Two Hearts that Beat as One in Tristan and Iseult

1396 words - 6 pages Two Hearts that Beat as One in Tristan and Iseult What causes two people in a relationship to be caught in an emotional roller coaster? There are many answers to this question. In the book, -The Romance of Tristan and Iseult, by Joseph Bedier, Tristan and Iseult had a relationship that can only be explained psychologically and spiritually. From the beginning of Tristans' childhood, he was born of misfortune that seemed to cycle throughout

The Role of the Princess in Jean Cocteau’s Film Orpheus

1042 words - 4 pages The Role of the Princess in Jean Cocteau’s Film Orpheus “As he lay in his bed, Orpheus’ Death would watch him sleep.” This is one of the most notable reoccurring behaviors of the princess of death in Jean Cocteau’s Orpheus. As made apparent, one of the many differences between Cocteau’s version of Orpheus and the Greek version is that death is personified through a female princess, rather than that of a male god. How does Cocteau embody death

The Personification of Death in Jean Cocteau’s Orpheus

873 words - 3 pages The Personification of Death in Jean Cocteau’s Orpheus The personification of Death is done by means of a princess of the Underworld in Jean Cocteau’s Orpheus. This Princess is very powerful, yet surprisingly vulnerable. For no one is allowed to love in the Underworld, the Princess falls in love with a famous poet named Orpheus and goes to drastic measures to be with him. But in the end she cannot be with her love, and she realizes this and

The Vicissitudes Of Romance and Love

1354 words - 5 pages by a sense of loss and change.” (Chapman.) Adela Pinch, also comments on Coleridge’s style of poetry stating “ Short poems of Mary Elizabeth Coleridge serve as examples of the ways in which fin-de-siecle poets tended to use short rhymed lines to express consciousness of the compression of time at the century's end.” (Pinch.) Although the previous two poems both expressed the unexpected in regards to romance, they cannot compare to the shock the

The Romance of Hamlet and Ophelia

874 words - 4 pages The most wonderful and intriguing topic for discussion is one of Shakespeare’s play has to be the relationship of Hamlet and Ophelia. Some people have doubted the love that is there, while others believed that there was love. Today in our current generation we still read and analyze this bond that they have. Everyone at least has experienced love in some kind of way to know how love should and should not feel, and even how love looks. So how

The Romance of Abelard and Heloise

2042 words - 8 pages The twelfth century was a period of revolutionary changes in religious, cultural, social, and intellectual life in Europe. The movement for the renewal of the marriage institution grew rapidly at that time. People awakened the question of the relevance of sexual and emotional aspects in marriage, and not only legal and religious views in the marital relationships. Peter Abelard was one of the greatest logicians and philosophers of the twelfth

The Vampire Lestat and the Problem of Eternal Damnation

4991 words - 20 pages The Tale of the Body Thief) This opinion would more than likely spare Lestat from eternal damnation, that God is not the perfect creation that the Bible tells us he is. Personal opinion plays a major part in the Vampire Chronicles, Louis believes they are all damned, Armand originally believes he is a servant of the Devil and Lestat believes he is the highest supernatural entity below Akasha, mother of all vampires. Again the theories of

Mice and Men, the True Beginning By: Tristan Horvath “Hey!

864 words - 3 pages Mice and Men, the True Beginning By: Tristan Horvath "Hey! What you boys doing in my yard?" I asked the two young men who were strolling across my yard. "Sorry sir, we were just cutting threw to get to the road," George tells the man. "Where you boys headed to?" I asked. "We're trying to find some work in Weed," George replies. "Well, what kind of work do you boys do?" "We can do anything sir. We're handy men and we also do hard labor work

Romance and Anti-Romance in Shakespeare's The Tempest

2201 words - 9 pages Romance and Anti-Romance in The Tempest       The specific genre classification that one may give to a piece such as The Tempest is often thought to be highly confusing. This is because so many of the qualities of a romance and a realism can be applied to it's words and actions, but at the same time pull away from the very sense of the genre that it is trying to achieve. A romance has many specific qualities, most of which rely on the

Interracial Intimacy: The Regulation of Race and Romance

1546 words - 6 pages Interracial Intimacy: The Regulation of Race and Romance Works Cited Missing Regardless of our social rhetoric of color-blindness, when it comes to choosing a spouse we seem to be remarkably aware of color, at least we were legally for more than 200 years and despite legal permission, society still exacts a social opinion on the matter. Law professor Rachel Moran examines this issue in Interracial Intimacy: The Regulation of Race and

Joseph And The Technicolor

603 words - 2 pages of his dreams he had to the two Pharaoh's servants, who the king did not like. One of the men became Pharaoh's cup servant after he got out of jail. Several years later, Pharaoh was bothered by horrible dreams and his cup servant told him about Joseph's weird ability to interpret dreams. Joseph was brought before Pharaoh and translated the dreams. The dreams told him of a coming food shortage. In return he was made the second most

Similar Essays

An Essay Depicting The Controversy Towards Religious Beliefs In Joseph Bedier's "The Romance Of Tristan & Iseult"

2535 words - 11 pages The theme of religion in Joseph Bedier's The Romance of Tristan & Iseult is extremely controversial. Throughout the story there are many conflicting scenes that portray a unique practice of Christianity. Tristan and Iseult believe in God and continuously ask for his protection, yet banish any belief of guilt for their adulteress actions due to the drinking of a magical love potion. Their guiltiness for the sins they commit are repeatedly

The Power Of Women In Sundiata And The Romance Of Tristan And Iseult

861 words - 4 pages Tristan and Iseult women do have power within the society. This power is shown through their knowledge, experience, and craftiness. This power that they possess in both the Epic and Romance story are crucial to the success and failure of both stories. Works Cited Bedier, Joseph. The Romance of Tristan and Iseult. New York: Vantage Books, 1994. Print. Niane, Djibril Tamsir., David W. Chappell, and Jim Jones. Sundiata: An Epic of Old Mali. Harlow, England: Pearson Longman, 2006. Print.

Consequences Of Passion Exposed In The Romance Of Tristan And Iseult

915 words - 4 pages Mark, while they burned with passions for each other. Closely analyzing this scenario, the reader of this story would have sympathy for Tristan and Iseult as "star-crossed lovers," to use the language of William Shakespeare in Romeo and Juliet. Work Cited Bedier, Joseph. The Romance of Tristan and Iseult. New York: Pantheon Books, 1964.

The Theme Of Disguise In "Tristan And Iseult" By Rosemary Sutcliff

890 words - 4 pages Disguises and impersonations appear often in Tristan and Iseult by Rosemary Sutcliff. They add to the story and are important in many of the themes throughout the book.Tristan has just been wounded, and as a last resort gets in a raft with no steering devices and sets him self to sea. He drifts toward some land, and hears some Irish men speaking, who have been told by the King to kill all men from Cornwall. Tristan has to disguise himself, but
Wet N Wild Silk Finish Lipstick Hot Red | Projecteurs DLP | Pergolesi, Il Flaminio