Meg Bogin's The Women Troubadours Essay

3048 words - 12 pages

Meg Bogin's The Women Troubadours

What is Bieiris de Romans’ speaker seeking from the woman, Maria, about whom Bieiris writes? More generally, what are female troubadours as a whole seeking from their loves, and their craft? Meg Bogin, in her The Women Troubadours, asserts that “their poems were addressed to women… to whom they vowed eternal homage and obedience. In exchange for their prostration, the troubadours expected to be ennobled, enriched, or simply made ‘better’” (Bogin, 9). Is the poetry of female troubadours less about the women being addressed and more about the troubadours themselves? By performing a close textual analysis of Bieiris de Romans’ poem to Maria, I hope to elucidate some possible answers to these questions.

The poem opens with Bieiris’ speaker addressing her subject as “Lady Maria.” Rather than merely employing the woman’s first name, or utilizing a possessive phrase such as “my love” or “my Maria,” the speaker addresses her as “lady.” This implies a certain bestowal of respect upon her subject, and is potentially also a means to convey an understanding on the speaker’s part that this Maria has not yet consented to be hers. Next, the speaker proceeds to enumerate copious qualities that she finds pleasing in Maria. She begins by praising Maria’s “merit and distinction.” By “distinction” we can safely assume that the speaker refers to a pleasing reputation that Maria has cultivated within society, and possibly also the speaker’s own opinion that Maria is able to be distinguished as superior to other women.

The term “merit,” however, is relatively ambiguous. By “merit,” the speaker could be indicating one or many qualities, including, but not limited to, virtue, achievement, and honor (“Merit”). The quality of “virtue” could suggest a monastic or spiritual inclination, yet it can also refer to a positive reputation in society. “Achievement” implies a more personal form of accomplishment, and “honor” may—like one possible connotation of virtue—refer to a sort of public praise for deeds performed or character demonstrated. Although a monastic or personal connotation is plausible, we neither have any evidence that Maria is particularly religious, nor that she has a close enough relationship with the speaker that any specific personal achievements of hers would be known. Also, considering that the word “merit” is coupled with “distinction,” we will make the claim that public honor and the enjoyment of a good reputation are what the speaker intends to signify by a meritorious quality.

In the next line, Bieiris’ speaker praises the “joy, intelligence and perfect beauty” of the lady Maria. This line appears to applaud the goodness of her spirit, mind, and body, respectively. In attributing to lady Maria a joyful spirit, an intelligent mind, and a perfectly beautiful physical appearance, is the speaker praising assets particular to this Maria, or is Bieiris merely conforming to a...

Find Another Essay On Meg Bogin's The Women Troubadours

Womanhood and Coming of Age in A Wrinkle in Time

1199 words - 5 pages can bring forth specific positive changes. The protagonist, Meg Murry, is a gifted adolescent who constantly harps on being different from other children. Her mother, Mrs. Murry, defines empowerment in women. Mrs. Murry is a phenomenal mother, devoted wife, and genius chemist. During the 1960s it was unheard of for women to be in a science career or many career fields that were limited to only men. The novel also follows Meg Murry’s literal and

Madeleine L'Engle A Wrinkle in Time

1690 words - 7 pages Women: Madeleine L’Engle). L’Engle develops Meg in a different reality than her own to explort the possibilities of what could have been if she had been able to handle difficult things. She gives Meg a big, happy family because she was lonely as an only child (Zarin). The choice of sending L’Engle off to so many boarding schools never allowed her to develop a sense of a stability, and she used her writing to synthesis a representation of it

Effects of Courtly Love on Medieval Women

1514 words - 6 pages This is an essay for my Women's History in Medieval Europe sophomore-level course. It discusses the effect of troubadours and courtly love practices on women of the High Middle Ages. Women were both empowered by these practices and also were made vulnerable.References to texts used in the course are made in parantheticals- not necessary to understanding the essay.Love overcomes both great and small,Love rules, for Love is lord of all."Fealty to

Married Women in Troubadour Lyric

1114 words - 5 pages Sex sells. It’s the clichéd advertising motto that pops into your head every time you turn on the television, and it’s true. From soap operas glorifying the drama of an affair to day-time talk shows mediating spurned spouses to news shows exposing philandering politicians, the more illicit the relationship, the better. The same maxim applied to medieval Occitania and the lyrics of the troubadours. Married women were frequently the subject of

Television drama: "Jessica"

1602 words - 6 pages guilty and sleep with her. This gives the idea that women cannot offer men much, other than sex and their bodies, and that they're prepared to do anything for them. Meg ends up succeeding in her pursuit for Jack, and when she becomes overwhelmed with guilt and fear, Hester orders Meg to "honour, love and obey." During the time that "honour [and] love" are being said, a shot of Meg's face is shown because they are things she expected to be present

Little Women Bliss

629 words - 3 pages In Louisa May Alcott’s novel, Little Women, some of the recurring themes include learning to appreciate what you have and that having money does not guarantee happiness-- family and love are just as important for the well being of oneself. These themes are taught to the five girls of the March family- Jo, Meg, Beth, and Amy- by their thoughtful, affectionate mother. The mother’s wisdom is gradually passed down to her four daughters, teaching

Deeper Meaning In A Wrinkle in Time

975 words - 4 pages submission and hatred. Therefore, Meg, and the other characters along for the journey, fight between conformity of the evil, or breaking free into goodness. Tracy M. Caldwell, an acclaimed critic in feminist and women studies, claims A Wrinkle in Time is a story "...of absolutes and facts while at the same time being capable of belief based entirely on faith and intuition." (Caldwell). While religion is implied rather than used

Realistic Dual Natures in Louisa May Alcott's Little Women

2138 words - 9 pages identify better with characters who are more like us--neither completely good nor bad.  Meg, Jo and Amy March in Alcott’s Little Women do not flatly portray complete good or complete evil, but their realistic dual natures increase their believability and intensify their moral influence on us.             This character duality is first evident in Margaret, the eldest sister, as we receive a description detailing her looks and countenance

Feminism and Society in "Little Women"

2012 words - 8 pages whether it goes along with their contemporary society or not. With the assistance of their mother, friends and experiences, Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy struggle between their personal expectations and society’s expectations as they plan for their future and choose their destinies. Mrs. March, also known as Marmee, like many women during this era had to learn how to balance working outside the home with raising a family while her

Spring Awakening, The Birthday Party, and Entertaining Mister Sloane

1272 words - 5 pages hinted upon during the third scene of Act One. It is the conversation between three young women. Martha has just told the reader that her family abuses her, “ For God’s sake Wendla! Papa beats me till I’m crippled and mama locks me up in he coal cellar for three nights at a time” (Wedekind 8). It is her next line that suggests exploitation; “Sometimes I think they’d miss something if they didn’t have a disgraceful brat like me!” (Wedekind 8) Miss

Little Women by Louisa Alcott and Persuasion by Jane Austen

1127 words - 5 pages poor men. Although Anne accepted the proposal and the changed her mind still show extreme similarities. Even with those similarities they have an important difference. Jo March is a tomboy and Anne Elliot is beautiful. Furthermore, the oldest sister in Little Women, Meg March can compare to the older sister in Persuasion Elizabeth Elliot in which a way that both of them are the better looking of all the sisters in the novels. The difference with

Similar Essays

Courtly Love In Meg Bogin’s "The Women Troubadours"

1375 words - 6 pages Maria de Ventadorn writes in a style common to the trobairitz of her time in the south of France. Meg Bogin’s collection The Women Troubadours will be used to outline general aspects of courtly love. This type of lyric is called a tenson, a common form of performed collaborative song with alternating stanzas (16). In the lyric, courtly love is presented as a game and Lady Maria’s interest is to win. This can be observed in the treatment of

The Greatest Literary Emblem Of The Middle Ages

2067 words - 8 pages France’s greatest hero, therefore influencing all troubadours, setting an example and an implicit guideline on how they had to behave and how they had to treat women in order for them to gain their love. Some of the most important troubadours were Guillaume IX, Bernart de Ventadorn, Jaufre Rudel, Piere Vidal, and Guiraut Riquier (Sigal) Concluding, the troubadours were the first creators of poetry in France, and most importantly, they were the

The Lives And Works Of The Troubadours, Trobaritz, And Trouvers

1366 words - 5 pages What were the troubadours, trobaritz, and trouvers and what were their lives like? This paper will offer a brief overview on the troubadours, trobaritz, and trouvers as well as give an introduction to each one, and explain the difference between them. Lastly, it will describe how they lived during the Middle Ages.Troubadours were noble poet-musicians from Southern France (Provence) who flourished from the end of the 11th century through to the

Meg Whitman President & Ceo Essay

780 words - 4 pages announced she would be running for governor of California. As a candidate, Meg showed her inexperience on the campaign trail. Following her political loss Meg who estimated to be worth more than $1 billion found that she was still interested in the business world. Meg Whitman is a pretty successful business woman Wall Street announced Meg as one of the fifty women to watch in 2005. Fortune ranked Meg one of the “50 women to watch in business in 2004
Comments: 0 | The Night Manager | Campark Sports Camera WiFi HD 4K Action Cam TouchScreen 20MP Video Helmet Camera