Morgan, Morgan By Janette Turner Hospital

1762 words - 7 pages

This paper will explore the short story “Morgan, Morgan” by Janette Turner Hospital in a poststructuralist way using both New Historicism and Deconstruction. First, we will explore the tenants of New Historicism and apply it to the story, and then we will explore the tenants of Deconstruction and apply it to the story. The ideals of New Historicism were first outlined by Michel Foucault and later developed by Stephen Greenblatt. Foucault did not develop New Historicism; however, his philosophy and ideas formed the basis of the practice. As Warren Hedges has noted,
Foucault’s contribution to literary studies has been to encourage us to think about how no writer’s description or categorization is simply neutral. Instead we can think about how writers further, complicate, or challenge the discourses of their time.
He goes on to say that, these discourses “promote specific kinds of power relations, usually favoring the ‘neutral’ person or professional.”

New Historicism as a literary practice didn’t come into being until the 1980’s when the questions raised by Foucault developed into practice, led by Stephen Greenblatt. This process was not instantaneous; it took a long time to fully develop into a series of reading practices. “New Historicism,” Hunter Cadzow writes,
Never was and never should be a theory; it is an array of reading practices that investigate a series of issues that emerge when critics seek to chart the ways texts, in dialectical fashion, both represent a society’s behavior patterns and perpetuate, shape, or alter that culture’s dominant codes.

Grandpa Morgan challenged his culture’s dominant codes and the discourses of his time. We see this represented in the passage relating to Uncle Charlie’s death. Morgan had an earthy spirituality that he had gained through his experiences in the world, and through his passion for gardening. He was deeply connected to the earth and to the soil, encouraging his dahlia’s to grow, crossbreed and continually become more healthy and beautiful. His faith was fluid, always growing. This is sharply contrasted with the unbending faith of the grandmother whose foundations were absolute and unchanging. The grandmother represents the dominant culture of religious faith. Her absolute and unbending “truth” that Uncle Charlie had gone “strait to heaven” (Lynn “Literature” 290) is a reflection of this culture whose ideas shape every fiber of the grandmother’s world. Grandpa Morgan, on the other hand, sees this viewpoint, and challenges it. He explains to the granddaughter that Uncle Charlie has simply died and been buried underground “with the dahlia bulbs” (Lynn “Literature” 290), deliberately referring to what happens to our bodies when we die. He ventured no guess as to where Uncle Charlie’s spirit may have gone. Grandpa Morgan knew that there was no simple or easy truth in the matter of death.

New historicism challenges our societal views, by asking the question...

Find Another Essay On Morgan, Morgan by Janette Turner Hospital

"My Place" by Sally Morgan: an Analysis

1391 words - 6 pages . Paternalism also led to the creation of a new identity caused by the loss of culture and heritage experienced by the Stolen Generation and the unacceptance of the white population. Another of the Stolen Generation, Arthur Corruna, tells of the hardships involved with being a half-caste and trying to get ahead in life. The fourth, Sally Morgan, the author, describes what it was like to grow up with a false sense of identity. She records the events in her

Slavery and Freedom: The American Paradox by Edmund Morgan

2220 words - 9 pages Elizabeth II. The letters patents, granted by the Queenes Majestie to M. Walter Ralegh, now Knight, for the discovering and planting of new lands and Countries, to continue the space of 6 yeeres and no more. Virginia: University of Virginia (etext). Online Morgan, Edmund. “The Labor Problem at Jamestown”. The American Historical Review. Online Morgan, Edmund. "Slavery and Freedom: The American Paradox." JSTOR.

Fat Head by Tom Naughton and Super Size Me by Morgan Spurlock

961 words - 4 pages As the rising epidemic of obesity has attracted considerable media attention, so has the promotion for maintaining healthy wellbeing. Tom Naughton’s documentary, Fat Head, is a stellar model of this media attention. It examines the exact cause of weight gain, and the reliability of the Government’s nutritional guidelines. The contention of Fat Head is that the U.S Government and Morgan Spurlock (the creator of Super Size Me) present misleading

Views on Slavery by Higginbotham, Jr.,Winthrop D. Jordan, and Edmund S. Morgan

2002 words - 9 pages Freedom: The American Paradox, by Edmund S. Morgan, seemingly takes the economic history view on slavery because in the end, slavery was very much needed if the colonists were to survive as a prosperous and powerful people. First in his introduction, Morgan clarifies the knowledge of Virginia not being the first to incorporate slavery by reminding his readers slavery existed as far back as the ancient time period. Morgan’s thesis revolves around

Inner Journey's - using "My Place" by Sally Morgan, Margaret Atwood's "Journey to the Interior" and others

1188 words - 5 pages Advanced English: Area of StudyInner JourneysTexts Used: "My Place" by Sally Morgan"Journeys", Board of Studies Stimulus Booklet* Inner Journeys. Eye contact.* Ladies and Gentlemen, I am here this morning to take you deeper into the possible meaning behind those two simple words.* My texts that I will be using today all have many links to the concept of the inner journey, and intertextual links with each other. My main prescribed texts are Sally

Charchter analysis of Rosa Morgan, from 'Welcome to the real world' by Ann Coburn

771 words - 3 pages Rosa Morgan is 14 years old. Her parents are teachers and they (especially her mother) have high expectations of her academic ability. She attends Seaton College and at the start of the novel she has been caught stealing a photograph of the popular boy that she secretly has a crush on, Jason. As a consequence Andrew Greenwood blackmails her. The story develops the theme of blackmail and bullying as Rosa learns that four other people are

This essay can be used as a book report of My Place, by Sally Morgan, or as an example of written history vs individual memory

1787 words - 7 pages Sally Morgan grew up unaware that she was Aboriginal. When, as an adult, she discovered her Aboriginal heritage, she was consumed by the desire to understand its significance:What did it really mean to be Aboriginal? I'd never lived off the land and been a hunter and a gatherer. I'd never participated in corroborees or heard stories of the Dreamtime. I'd lived all my life in Suburbia and told everyone I was Indian. I hardly knew any Aboriginal

Lessons that Spencer Morgan learned from the war: Reader response from "Soldier Boys" by Dean Hughes. describes 2 lessons spencer learned from WW2

658 words - 3 pages Reader Response: Spencer's lessons in the War from "Soldier Boys" by Dean HughesMany of the men who enlisted in World War Two were not actual men, but merely boys, wanting to be heroic and do something to support their country. One of these boys, Spencer Morgan, was only seventeen when he enlisted. He, like many others, wanted to prove himself, to be a hero, even if he was known only in his little hometown of Brigham City, Utah. Spencer soon

My Place by Sally Morgan in relation to the movie Fight Club by David Fincher, the painting Cathedral by Jackson Pollock and the poem Kith of Infinity by Somtow Sucharitkul

4076 words - 16 pages My Place by Sally Morgan (Fight Club, Cathedral and Kith of Infinity) Fight Club Fight Club is a movie directed by David Fincher and written by Chuck Palahniuk. It is a satire on the dehumanizing effects of consumer culture that forms the backbone of the American Dream as it tells the story of an unnamed man, a child of generation X, "a generation of men raised by women", who is on a journey to recover his sense of masculinity. To do this, he

Inner journeys and "My Place" by Sally Morgan

651 words - 3 pages feel embarrassed now to think that once I wanted to be white...I've changed since those days" The natural vernacular used by Gladys gives her story individuality and through the use of everyday language positions the wider audience to respond to the story. Her changing viewpoint about her preferred skin colour signifies personal growth and development as she is now accepting herself holistically rather then in fragments.Daisy's life has been scarred

Aread of study : Journey - My Place by: Sally Morgan - 'Variety is the spice of life.' Discuss with reference to your prescribed text and other material you have studied

2109 words - 8 pages The destination is where a person may gain a limited amount of information, but it is the inner journey or human experience that forms who people are today. This is shown in the poem "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" by Robert Frost, a cartoon from the book "You & me" by Michael Leunig & the stimulus texts "The Town Where Time Stands Still" by Shirley Geok-lin Lim, "Journey to the Interior" by Margaret Atwood & "The Road Not

Similar Essays

"Super Size Me" By Morgan Spurlock

646 words - 3 pages Key Performers: Morgan Spurlock, Daryl M. Isaacs M.D., Bridget Bennett, RD., Healthy Chef Alex (Morgan's Wife)Did you like this movie? Why/why not?Although "Super Size Me" was a very disturbing movie, I enjoyed it. Morgan Spurlock did a great job of showing that fast food might taste good, but we need to be careful about how and when we eat it. I also enjoyed it because the music to the movie was catchy and it sticks in your head.In what way did

Benjamin Franklin Written By Edmund S. Morgan

720 words - 3 pages The name of the book I reviewed was Benjamin Franklin written by Edmund S. Morgan, published by Yale University Press in 2002. The author states the purpose of writing this book was to expose the true Benjamin Franklin that has been misrepresented by scholars in the past. Morgan used the numerous letters Franklin exchanged between his friends and an autobiography to develop this book.The book begins by the author asking his readers to overcome

Super Size Me, By Morgan Spurlock

1260 words - 5 pages connection with obesity in America. In his documentary Spurlock performs a radical experiment that drives him to eat only from McDonald's and order a super-sized meal whenever he is asked. By including visual and textual techniques, rhetorical appeals, and argumentative evidences, Morgan Spurlock was able to help viewers know the risks of fast food and how it has caused America to be the world's “fattest country”. The first step that Spurlock

Glasgow 5 March 1971 By Edwin Morgan

1248 words - 5 pages Glasgow 5 March 1971 by Edwin Morgan ‘Glasgow 5 March 1971’ is a poem by Edwin Morgan which creates a picture of a corrupt figure, but in a way the corrupt figure can be seen as a hero if we look at the poem in the corrupt figures point of view, but generally no one would classify the corrupt figures of being heroes. The poem ‘Glasgow 5 March 1971’ is an instamatic poem, where the poet approaches to give an insight into the violent
Des Moines Homestyle March 2012 | Principal | avant 2010