Should Iraq Become A Democracy? A Platonic Perspective

2211 words - 9 pages

Every once in a while it is a good idea to take a step back and question why we believe the things that we do. Reading Plato's Republic reminded me of this, and forced me to re-evaluate my belief that everybody should be entitled to a democracy. Previously, I could not understand why such hostility came from other countries, especially Iraq, on the good and honorable act of the U.S. by freeing Iraq from a dictator. Additionally, Iraq is finally able to become a democracy, where the people decide how to run the country. In his Republic, Plato constructs a convincing argument about the evils and deterioration that result from such a permissive style of living. Similarly, many Iraqi's have also spoken out against the fundamental disagreements between theocracy and democracy. These ideas have lead me to conclude that Iraqi's have a deeper understanding the underside of democracy that Plato depicts and also the long-term implications that result from total liberty.

Plato's understanding of democracy can be found in the Republic VIII (555 b-565 c). The surrounding passages describe Plato's bigger depiction of the breakdown of political systems. He writes that the best system of government is an aristocracy where the intellectuals run the polity based on intellectual skill alone (545 b). An aristocracy gets degraded to a timocracy (545 c-547 c), which further deteriorates to an oligarchy (550 c-551b), finally a democracy is born. Democracy is the second worst political system, right behind a tyranny. It is described as the breakdown of an oligarchy--a system which is greedy, yet still restrained by the greed in order to maintain wealth. This change results in a shift of values; from some moderation to full freedom. As greed sets in, the wise have already lost their appeal in the shift from timocracy to oligarchy. Now, instead of hoarding their money, the democratic society wants to enjoy it (555 b-557 a).

Plato further argues that human cravings do not have a natural limit, people live in excess. Ultimately this is the final step in the destruction of a society. Plato emphasizes that knowledge of natural limits is instilled by parents during childhood, but further practice is needed. He then specifies what natural limits are using an analogy. The analogy is meant to distinguish between necessary and unnecessary pleasures. An example of a necessary pleasure is food. The necessity of food is obvious, but since most of us enjoy eating when hungry, food is also a pleasure. These necessary pleasures are taught, and then implemented through practice. However, the unnecessary pleasures could be compared to foods that taste good, but rot in our stomach and eventually lead to sickness. But the justification is that eating regular food when we are hungry three times a day gets mundane; especially if we have the option to eat three more times in a day, thereby experiencing three more incidences of pleasure (559 b-c). Plato is...

Find Another Essay On Should Iraq Become a Democracy? a Platonic Perspective

Should Quebec become a "distinct society" in Canada?

891 words - 4 pages . Because Canada was fighting for Britain, Canada's mother nation, Quebec didn't think that they should fight. They don't feel like they had the need to fight for the King of England and fight Germany. They were never loyal to Britain. BUT because of the riots, PM Mackenzie tried to cancel out conscription. Unfortunately, WW2 came along and Mackenzie King held a referendum to see if the Canadians wanted to bring out conscription. The English

Should Civil Disobedience Be Permitted In A Democracy?

520 words - 2 pages that we take for granted today.Civil disobedience should be permitted in a democracy. Afterall, it wouldn't be a democracy if people didn't have the right to express their views and opinions. It also gives the government a chance to see what laws are unjust so they can be changes to benefit society more.

Should Civil Disobedience Be Permitted In A Democracy?

520 words - 2 pages that we take for granted today.Civil disobedience should be permitted in a democracy. Afterall, it wouldn't be a democracy if people didn't have the right to express their views and opinions. It also gives the government a chance to see what laws are unjust so they can be changes to benefit society more.

A brief survey of Presocratic and Platonic metaphysics

1663 words - 7 pages replaced, are we a new person when none of our original cells exist?This is a perfect example of one of the classic problems from the history of metaphysics: the problem of change. This problem was as vexing to the ancient Greeks as it is to the modern mind. Should we assume that what we see and feel what is actually the way we think it to be? For philosophers concerned with metaphysics (literally translated as beyond-physics), the answer is most

Against a War Against Iraq

941 words - 4 pages Japanese Internet news programs and any other countries’ news on the Internet, I realized that this war is not only a matter between the US and Iraq because of possible damage by nuclear weapons and other possible damage, which many countries all over the world may have because of this war. Therefore this war should be finished as soon as possible. First, this war badly affects Iraqi people’s states of mind because people are worried

Constructing a Democracy

1631 words - 7 pages Introduction The construction of a democracy requires vision, ambition and decisiveness because democrats must not only construct the constitution of liberty for their homelands but also build a democracy that delivers a competent state, respectful of its citizens. Democratic designers must construct a regime that rests on a workable balance between the hopes and constraints of their societies and a constitution and institutions that would

Australia should become a Republic - Persuasive Argument with Pros and Cons

818 words - 3 pages democracy works. Federation has its ups and downs and people change their minds. A poll held two years ago shows that 30% of people voted for the Queen to remain head of the state. This shows that more and more Australians believe that we should become a republic. I think that this is the way to go. Its time for a revolution!Bibliography:http://www.actnow.com.au/Issues/Australian_republic_debate.aspxhttp://my.integritynet.com.au/purdic/vivalarepublic.htmhttp://home.alphalink.com.au/~eureka/case2.htmhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_republicanismhttp://www.republic.org.au/homepagehtml.htmhttp://www.norepublic.com.au/

In A Democracy

649 words - 3 pages In a Democracy...."Men do not seek authority so that they may impose policy, they seek policy so that they may achieve authority"The campaign promise is the trademark of our political candidates. They have staffers that research what issues are of utmost importance to the American People then they bombard my television with ads that if elected they will impose policy that I, as a citizen have stated I desire. But more often than not the promises

France: A Socialist Democracy

1481 words - 6 pages the parliament whenever he sees fit and the current President, François Hollande, is a part of the socialist party. France’s socialism has also achieved a 40-hour work week, paid vacations, the abolishment of capital punishment, and decentralization of power. Contrary to the traditional American belief, which is that democracy and capitalism is the best for every country, socialism is not evil and can work. France has been a successful and

Democracy As A Myth

1552 words - 6 pages become the only constant.The challenge for organizations is whether they can become flexible enough, fast enough. And will they do it on terms set by the organizational culture, and then adapt and succeed in the face of it or will they challenge the status quo and attempt to transform the prevailing culture. What follows is the story of a public organization, which is trying to change the context under which it performs rather than be changed by

Transitioning into a Democracy

1651 words - 7 pages refugees, and violent acts. Sharing borders with the United States makes for easy transport of millions of dollars' worth of drugs into the country. Higher security measures at the US/ Mexico border caused to the cartel to expand and travel to other failing and corrupt states in Africa. Africa has become a new destination for the cartel to travel to and unload drugs to be spread across borders all over the world. Organized crime and terrorist groups

Similar Essays

Would A Democracy Succeed In Iraq?

525 words - 2 pages should have the power to govern their country a democracy will only bring more chaos. Only a little more than fifty percent of males in Iraq can read, but that is a majority compared to the twenty five percent literacy rate in females. At the moment the people of Iraq are unable to make decisions that would best help them. A representative for the country may try to do good for the whole but he will be unable to because the people will not know what

Should Australia Become A Republic? Essay

1178 words - 5 pages may not show the same impartiality. Some argue that Australia should not become a republic due to the British monarch being apart of our culture and heritage. Many feel a sense of duty and pride towards the British monarch. The current system of government holds the benefits of a constitutional monarchy and also of democratic freedom. Some may argue that becoming a republic is an unnecessary cost and will just waste taxpayers money

Should Euthanasia Be Legalised? A Moral Perspective

2127 words - 9 pages that the consequences of proposed euthanasia laws, though they have not come to pass, have certainly caused the debate of ethical and legal issues and thus, it is proposed that euthanasia should not yet be legalised. This argument will be supported with examples from Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act, as well as incorporate statistics found in a study of end-of-life decisions in six European countries published in 2003. This supporting evidence will

A Look In To The Platonic Soul

1509 words - 6 pages A Look into the Platonic soulIn Plato's Republic, Socrates explains his idea of the moral soul being an ideal soul. Socrates' proved this by comparing an ideal soul to an ideal society. This analogy allowed Socrates to develop a theory for the composition of the soul. This theory proposes that the mind is divided into 3 parts; the rational part, the passionate part and the appetites. In his ideal soul the rational part is in charge, much like a
Grimore x Reverse - Tensei Kishin Roumantan | Pierre Étaix | Tema anterior