Siobhan Somerville’s Essay Passing Through The Closet In Pauline E. Hopkins’s Contending Forces

2353 words - 9 pages

Siobhan Somerville’s essay “Passing through the Closet in Pauline E. Hopkins’s Contending Forces”

In Siobhan Somerville’s essay, “Passing through the Closet in Pauline E. Hopkins’s Contending Forces”, the tacit allusion to homosexuality within Hopkins’ story is argued to be a resource used to question the dominance or implicit strength of heterosexuality in the African-American community over Black women. While I do believe Hopkins may have intended for the novel to raise questions about the institution of marriage in relation to the African-American female, I do not believe the argument is as polarized as a difference between homosexual and heterosexual attraction in relation to politics between the sexes. Instead, I would argue that the very ambiguity of sexuality within the text serves to comment on a larger issue of what makes a woman female and the importance of intimate bonds between women in society.

The most important piece of textual evidence in Somerville’s argument is the attic scene between Dora and Sappho. In this scene Sappho begs Dora to spend the morning with her after a snowstorm from the previous night makes it impossible for her to go to work. The two lock themselves away in Sappho’s attic apartment and commence to have a tea party and “play ‘company’ like the children” (Hopkins 117). In her essay, Somerville describes this as a highly sexualized scene, in which the intimacy between the two women hints at a possible homosexual attraction between the two, given the homoerotic description of their affection towards one another (Somerville 149-152). While I do believe the scene does have a certain element of homoerotic tension, I would not go so far as to polarize the scene as clearly “homosexual” as “a potential obstacle to the expected heterosexual coupling” (151). Rather, I would say Dora expresses another type of emotional strain in regards to heterosexual marriage. The homoerotic moment between these two women demonstrate a network of affection and understanding well outside the boundaries of marriage, which existed solely between women.

In Carroll Smith-Rosenberg’s essay, “The Female World of Love and Ritual,” the concept of “female friendship” is seen as a product of “cultural and social setting rather than from an exclusively individual psychosexual perspective” (Smith-Rosenberg 2). From her insightful readings of letters sent between women during the early to late nineteenth century, close female relationships seem to foster a type of network of support between women existing far outside of the realm of the heterosexual courtship society. These interactions ranged from intensely physical and emotional confidences between women, which by today’s standard would be seen as potential homosexual revelations, to ‘average’ platonic declarations of love. In any case, it would appear that the social standard for same-sexed bonds was much more flexible and intimate in the early 1900s than it is today, most likely due to...

Find Another Essay On Siobhan Somerville’s essay Passing through the Closet in Pauline E. Hopkins’s Contending Forces

Sororophobia by Helena Michie and Black Female Sexuality in Passing by Deborah E. McDowel

1955 words - 8 pages unpleasantly. So while it may seem beneficial to “pass,” the end result is that the truth will come out. Literary articles which critique “Passing” such as “Sororophobia” by Helena Michie and “Black Female Sexuality in Passing” by Deborah E. McDowell discusses the issues of passing. Juanita Ellsworth’s “White Negros” provide scenarios where skin color played a factor in education and professional experiences. Louis Fremont Baldwin’s “Negro to

Analise E.on UK, through studying industry dynamics and Porter's 5 Forces. Identify competitiveness of the key marketing features in the company, through studying product life cycle and innovation

2297 words - 9 pages product proves successful, it enters the introduction stage. Next is the growth stage; the product is still new in the market but everyone already desires it, thus sales are growing rapidly. At this stage, the firm usually expects to enjoy economies of scale. After passing through all these stages, the product enters the maturity and saturation stage. At the maturity stage sales peak and competition is extremely high, as growth can only be achieved

The Complexities of Human Relationships Explored in Nella Larsen's Passing

2494 words - 10 pages novel, Passing, focuses on this idea with the story of Clare Kendry, a tragic mulatto who "passes" as a white person. Not only is Passing representative of the dilemma of the tragic mulatto, it is also a novel that explores the difficulties of human relationships.      Clare Kendry's life is a great example of the difficulty of the tragic mulatto. In Passing, Clare seems to have and urge to go back to the African American world she left. Clare

“Let’s Put Pornography Back in the Closet” by Susan Brownmiller: Analysis of an Argument

614 words - 2 pages In “Let’s Put Pornography Back in the Closet,” Brownmiller discusses her views on the First Amendment and pornography. She explains that pornography has become a disturbingly common sight and there should be some type of restrictions put forth to protect the people who are subject to seeing such obscene materials. Brownmiller uses her feminist views to convince the reader that these restrictions are needed, but only in cases dealing with

Essay on Manipulation through Language in The Memorandum

1323 words - 5 pages Manipulation through Language in The Memorandum     How one utilizes language to perpetuate certain images or perspectives can greatly influence the way people think. One can use language to manipulate the minds of others and bring them under some form of subjugation. In Vaclav Havel's The Memorandum certain characters use this tactic of manipulation through different means that involve language, and in the process, they gain the

Letter “e” and The Cheek Cells through a Microscope

1057 words - 4 pages about the letter “e” and the cheek cells. For example, in the letter “e”, the ink under the microscope is thin and dull. Comparing a normal view, the ink is thick and dark. The letter “e” is being thin, because it gives a clear details of what the newspaper letter “e” looks like. When moving the slide to the right. Looking through the ocular lens, it moved toward the left. The letter “e” moves toward the opposite direction. When the slide is moved

A Career in the Armed Forces

731 words - 3 pages One of the largest and every growing career fields in the U.S is in the armed forces whether its the Marines,Air Force, Navy, or Army each offer a widespread variety of job opportunities some general and others more specified to a certain career field like medicine or Mechanics. However to first be able to enlist in the armed forces one must take the ASVAP which is a general test covering different areas from math to english to basic knowledge

The Supernatural Forces in Macbeth by Shakespeare

853 words - 4 pages Regardless of your position on supernatural events in our world, you have to acknowledge the supernatural forces at play in Shakespeare’s Macbeth. In our society, we hear the occasional ghost stories or urban legends, hinting at an entanglement between our world and one more supernatural. However, when you look into the world of Macbeth, you are thrown into a world of witches, ghosts, and prophecies, all of which have very real influence upon

The passing of the torch in the novel "Deliverance", by James Dickey

822 words - 3 pages passing of the torch took place.Throughout life, many things and people can take control of our lives. Having a job or a career can be a controlling force. Having a committed relationship can be a controlling force. However, none of these controlling forces really offer a 'passing of the torch' experience. When in a military situation, many opportunities to pass the torch can come about. One is when a man or women advances in rank. One example of

Skeleton's in the Closet. A creative imaginative story about a deadly disease threatening to kill all life on earth

1353 words - 5 pages old bomb shelters, as the disease has not yet been reported to pass through solid walls. The disease however can pass through cracks in walls having a devastating effect, as it wipes out the large numbers of people that have packed into the building or shelter in a matter of minutes. Human, animal and plant numbers as halved since the outbreak a few days ago, and it seems that even if people keep hiding they will be avoiding the inevitable as at

"Passing" in James Weldon Johnson’s The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man

1108 words - 4 pages is “passing” as a black; he is treated differently than when he is “passing” for white (Johnson 95). This “freemasonry” is what convinces him the white society is the dominant culture. Success can only be accomplished in the white society. Through the exploitation of ragtime, he observes a black person can do something and earn “only a few dollars” while a white person can take what the “negro originators” did and “earn small fortunes” solely due

Similar Essays

Analyse Two Texts On The Module In The Light Of The Linda Hutcheon’s And Siobhan O’flynn’s Assertion That ‘Part Of Th[E] Pleasure [Of Consuming Ad

2151 words - 9 pages . However they all had something in common; “most of the films emphasised the romantic story lines, glamorised the appearance of the main characters, altered the male hero, and offered a sentimental view of the English estate and landscape ”. These adaptations had adhered to the opinion stated in the essay title that “th[e] pleasure [of consuming adaptations] comes simply from repetition with variation ” as they had all, to varying degrees

Essay Is About The Character Pauline And Her Many Perversions Of Life In Louise Erdrich's "Tracks"

1454 words - 6 pages Pauline's Exocentric Identity in Louise Erdrich's "Tracks"During the novel "Tracks" (1988) Louise Erdrich (Anishinaabe) devolves her characters with personality and physical distinctions enabling them to come alive. As Erdrich's most culturally diverse character, Pauline is developed into a distinct and idle shape that is molded and expressed in a unique way. Pauline's exocentric character guides her through the novel with unmatched identity and

Homosexuals: Coming Out Of The Closet In Angels In America

1580 words - 6 pages Roy because he is not a professional. Prior is also affected by the AIDS virus, and is close to passing away. Joe Pitt is the prime example of a homosexual man coming out into a society that doesn't accept gay relationships. Joe is the only person in the play who undergoes the process of coming out of the closet. Joe is married to Harper, a woman who is addicted to drugs. He is like Roy in that he is a well-respected person whose career

Analysis Of The Closet Scene In Hamlet The Movie

821 words - 3 pages closet scene. Traditionally a Queen's closet was not worth emphasizing a bedroom, but it is likely that most of the readers would presume that the closet scene takes place in Gertrude?s bedroom because of the obsession that Hamlet has about Gertrude?s bed. When Hamlet responds to his mother?s summons and comes to her closet, he invades a very private place where customarily a woman would only entertain her husband or a lover. For an adult son
Development of Personal Computers - 2518 Words | Miles Brown | Notebook for Golf Clash APK Modded