The Triangular Silas Marner Essay

2817 words - 11 pages

The Triangular Silas Marner

 
      As a result of betrayal, Silas Marner of George Eliot's so titled novel becomes a man in body without incurring any of the duties normally associated with nineteenth century working class adults. Eliot creates these unusual circumstances by framing our title-hero so it appears to his comrades that he has stolen money. Thereby, she effectively rejects innocent Marner from his community and causes him to lose his fiancé. At this pivotal moment in Marner's life, just as he is about to assume fully the role of a man, depended upon as such by his neighbors, future wife and probable children, he is excised and does not successfully complete the transformation. Accordingly, he moves on to a new place, Raveloe, with the same carefree lack of responsibility as a boy, who is clearly unable to act like the man he seems he should be.

 

By denying Marner the possibility of a traditional family from the start, Eliot immediately brings forward the question of family values. A question that she answers in the course of her novel. Jeff Nunokawa, in his essay The Miser's Two Bodies: Silas Marner and the Sexual Possibilities of the Commodity, claims that Eliot "simply" shows "support for family values" (Nunokawa 273), and that she "encourages" them through her narrative (Nunokawa 290). As evidence, he cites quotations from the text that paint, as he puts it, "men [living] without women... in a barren region" (Nunokawa 273). Adeptly, he points to Eliot's line, "The maiden was lost... and then what was left to them?'" (Nunokawa 273). Furthermore, Nunokawa goes on to label the moral implications of the novel as those of a "blunt dichotomy," saying that Eliot hands her reader "the evil of the gold" in direct contrast to "the goodness of the child [Eppie]" (Nunokawa 274).

 

I do not disagree with Nunokawa's easily supported primary claim that men who lack women in Silas Marner are not happy. However, I do not think that Silas Marner's endorsement of family values is nearly as straightforward as Nunokawa makes it out to be. In fact, Eliot's stance on the family unit is three-pronged. Nunokawa's reduction of Silas Marner to a "dichotomy" ignores the middle ground that Eliot ultimately recommends as the key to a life with a happy ending.

 

In order to demonstrate this, I must first show that none of the families in Silas Marner (with the exception of Silas' own) are totally happy. In accord with Nunokawa, I will start with the uncomplicated melancholy of Squire Cass' male-only family. Eliot candidly tells her reader that "Red House [the Squire's residence] was without the presence of the wife and mother which is the fountain of wholesome love and fear in parlour and kitchen" (Eliot 22). Immediately, Eliot prepares her reader for an unhappy, incomplete group of inhabitants. The only scene between father and eldest son is both awkward and unkind, showing the attitude of...

Find Another Essay On The Triangular Silas Marner

Comparing The Three Fathers In Silas Marner

4569 words - 18 pages Comparing The Three Fathers In Silas Marner Silas Marner, is a book of great depth, considering many types of situations that people still find themselves in today. It gives us an inner view on how people used cope with their troubles during the period of the industrial revolution, be they minor or major ones. George Eliot reveals human nature perceptively, humourously, and extremely intelligently. She is a brilliant

The Pearl, The Good Earth, and Silas Marner

663 words - 3 pages One major theme that runs through The Pearl, The Good Earth, and Silas Marner is the impact of money on the lives of the characters. All three books vividly incorporate this theme in different ways. Money can greatly alter the way of life of any individual. It can be an advantage or a disadvantage. These three authors used this theme in these novels to show the reader the impact money can have on a person. In John Steinbeck’s, The Pearl

"The Fotunes Of Silas Marner" By George Eliot

1801 words - 8 pages A Study into the Fortunes of Silas Marner.George Eliot wrote Silas Marner in 1861. It is set in a time before the Industrial Revolution, a world that our society is unaware of. It is in a time where cloth was made at home in a weaver's cottage, rather than in large factories of mass production. Silas is a cottage weaver.Silas Marner's fortunes throughout the book are many and varied. Although throughout the story he receives many setbacks and

The Importance of Duty in George Eliot's Silas Marner

3782 words - 15 pages The Importance of Duty in George Eliot's Silas Marner In George Eliot's novel, 'Silas Marner', there is much evidence to suggest that duty is important. In the novel 'Silas Marner', duty is presented through parenting and community. Duty means conducts that are due to others. Duties are various functions that we have to follow, and they are moral obligations to others. This is all true for this novel, but also it means

The Changes Eppie Brings to Silas' Life in George Eliot's Silas Marner

2949 words - 12 pages The Changes Eppie Brings to Silas' Life in George Eliot's Silas Marner "A Child, More Than All Other ============================= Gifts That Earth Can Offer To Declining Man, Brings Hope With It, And Forward-looking Thoughts." What Changes Does Eppie Bring About In -------------------------------------- Silas's Life? The motto chosen by George Eliot for the title page of the novel means

The Portrayal of the Community in Raveloe in Silas Marner by George Eliot

4270 words - 17 pages The Portrayal of the Community in Raveloe in Silas Marner by George Eliot Silas Marner by George Eliot was first published in 1861 during the industrial revolution. The industrial revolution, as the transformation came to be called, caused a sustained rise in real income per person in England and, as its effects spread, the rest of the Western world. Historians agree that the industrial revolution was one of the most

The Theme of an Oustider in Silas Marner and To Kill a Mockingbird

2872 words - 11 pages Discuss the theme of an oustider in Silas Marner and To Kill a Mockingbird. What is an outsider? The dictionary defines that an outsider is a person excluded from a group. The outsider plays an important part in both novels. In 'Silas Marner' by George Eliot Silas is the main outsider, however in 'To Kill a Mockingbird' by Harper Lee even though Boo is the obvious outsider there are many others. 'Silas Marner' is written by George

How the Character of Silas Marner has Changed Throughout George Eliot's Novel

3363 words - 13 pages How the Character of Silas Marner has Changed Throughout George Eliot's Novel George Eliot, (1819-1880), was the pseudonym of Mary Anne Evans, she English novelist, whose novels, with their profound feeling and broad intellectual range, raised her immediately to the first rank of English writers. She changed her name to George Elliot because women were not looked upon as writers. When George Eliot wrote her novels she

The Instances of Injustice and Justice in To Kill A Mocking Bird and Silas Marner

3448 words - 14 pages The Instances of Injustice and Justice in To Kill A Mocking Bird and Silas Marner In this essay I am going to compare and contrast the instances of injustice and justice in "To Kill A Mockingbird" and "Silas Marner". "To Kill A Mockingbird" is set in Maycomb, in the southern state of Alabama during the years, 1933-35, the time of the Great Economic Depression. Racial prejudice was particularly strong in the Southern

The Relationship Between Parents and Their Children in Silas Marner by George Eliot

2467 words - 10 pages The Relationship Between Parents and Their Children in Silas Marner by George Eliot "A child more than all other gifts That Earth can offer to a declining man Brings hope with it and forward looking thoughts." William

An essay analysing the theme of outsider in 'To Kill A Mockingbird' by Harper Lee and 'Silas Marner' by George Elliot

3012 words - 12 pages Discuss the theme of outsider in 'Silas Marner' and 'To Kill A Mockingbird'The theme of 'outsider' runs throughout both 'Silas Marner', written by Harper Lee, and 'To Kill A Mockingbird', written by George Eliot. Many other similarities exist between the two novels as well. Both novels are written by women in a time were oppression, segregation and prejudice were around in some force. Both novels involve a character that is an outsider by

Similar Essays

The Portrayal Of Silas Marner Essay

2241 words - 9 pages In this essay I aim to discuss the portrayal of Silas Marner in chapters 1, 2 and 14 in the novel. The story of Silas Marner is about how things can change in time. It also supplies a certain message. George Elliot wrote the story in 1860. George Elliot was a female and her real name was Marian Evans. She changed her name because it was difficult for a woman’s book to be published. Her story deals with themes of greed, jealousy and envy

Silas Marner And The Community Essay

738 words - 3 pages The most prominent theme in Silas Marner is that of community. The book opens with Marner in the little town of Raveloe, we learn in the beginning of the book about the significance of the town in an individuals life. Your community was your way of life, if local farmers did not like you then they would not provide you with sustenance. Marner plays a very peculiar role in Raveloe; he talks to others only when he needs to and has no friends. He

The Response Of The Community To Silas In Silas Marner

2634 words - 11 pages The Response of the Community to Silas in Silas Marner When Silas Marner arrived in Raveloe the villagers did not show a very hospitable welcome to him, they saw him as an outsider, 'an alien-looking man'. This was the normal reaction to new comers in Raveloe. It was a small village, 'where many of the old echoes lingered, undrowned by new voices'. The village based itself mainly around the church, which 'once showed

The Growth Of George Eliot's Silas Marner

1997 words - 8 pages The Growth of Silas Marner        Silas Marner is introduced as a "pallid young man, with prominent, short-sighted brown eyes" who led a quiet life in the small country community, Lantern Yard. He is a skilled hand loom-weaver of "exemplary life and ardent faith"; His work, friends and faith have a huge part in his life, making him an open and honest person. Silas certainly possesses a flawed character, which we see quite clearly in his
XXL BABY SHOPPING 🛍 👶🏼 Er wird so schnell groß .. | Bibi | ボトムス | KUMPULAN LAGU PONGDUT KENDANG PALING NENDANG Blekuk Blekuk.mp3